
Initial Business Situation
NASM, a nationally recognized certification provider in the fitness space, had been running paid media across platforms like TikTok and Meta, but performance had hit a wall. CAC was rising. Creative was under-optimized.
Most importantly, they weren’t tapping into TikTok’s full funnel potential, which limited their ability to scale new leads cost-effectively.
Frustrations
Despite a strong brand and large audience, NASM was stuck in “spray and pray” mode with social ads, producing generic creatives and struggling to make TikTok profitable. Their cost per lead was inconsistent, and TikTok was viewed more as an awareness channel than a conversion tool.
Risks & Pressure
With economic uncertainty pressuring budgets, leadership needed proof that TikTok could perform beyond vanity metrics. Otherwise, they’d be forced to pull back investment.

Discovery Phase
Disruptive partnered with NASM to reframe TikTok from a top-of-funnel-only tool to a true full-funnel performance channel. Key insights included:
- TikTok’s native behavior required creative made for the platform, not repurposed from Meta.
- Successful users were engaging with UGC, hooks, and direct problem/solution narratives, none of which NASM had deployed at scale.
- A creative bottleneck was blocking performance more than audience targeting or budget.
Strategy & Execution
We overhauled NASM’s paid social strategy across TikTok and Meta with a focus on:
- UGC-style creative built from scratch using influencer-style content, designed to build trust and convert.
- Direct CTA hooks that used attention-grabbing intros and credentialed authority (like “How I got certified with NASM”).
- Full funnel structure with creative segmented by audience stage and expanded beyond awareness-only formats.
Creative Strategy Wins
- Introduced over 40 new TikTok creatives across 4 months.
- Launched “proof-first” ads featuring NASM certification holders in action.
- Tested user-generated storytelling against benefit-focused static formats. UGC drove the most efficient CAC.

Hard Metrics
- 235% increase in free signups YoY from TikTok
- 33% lift in eCommerce sales YoY
- 10% reduction in cost per opportunity YoY
- 37% increase in average opportunity value YoY
TikTok-Specific Wins
- TikTok CAC dropped by 60% from Q1 to Q3
- Multiple creative concepts outperformed platform benchmarks in CTR and watch time
- NASM’s in-platform ROAS for TikTok increased 4x across the engagement funnel

Strategic Takeaway
This wasn’t just a win for TikTok. It was a full funnel realignment. By focusing on executional excellence in creative and audience segmentation, NASM turned a flatlining ad channel into a scalable growth engine.

“We’ve never seen TikTok drive actual leads like this before. Disruptive’s creative strategy turned a frustrating channel into one of our top performers.”
— VP, Growth Marketing, NASM

