
Initial Business Situation
When Wisdom Teeth Guys launched into the San Antonio market, they were ready to grow fast. But instead of booking surgeries, they were burning cash. Their cost per acquisition (CPA) ballooned to $250—well over their $100 target.
They had campaigns running, keywords picked, budgets set. But the results? Brutal.
What Wasn’t Working
Their paid search strategy cast a wide net, bidding on broad terms like “oral surgeons” and “dental practices.” That got clicks—but not customers. High-volume traffic with low conversion rates = wasted ad spend.
Emotional State
The team was frustrated. “We’re spending more, but seeing less.” Every week felt like rolling dice with their marketing budget. They weren’t just worried about efficiency—they were questioning if San Antonio could even be a profitable market.

Discovery Phase
When we dug in, one insight hit like a wisdom tooth at 3AM: Not all keywords are created equal.
We analyzed every conversion and uncovered something big: The traffic that actually booked surgeries came from very specific, high-intent terms—like “wisdom teeth removal near me” and “get wisdom teeth out fast.”
The broad stuff? Dead weight.
So we made a bold move: we scrapped 90% of the keyword strategy and went all-in on what worked.
Implementation
Here’s what we did:
- Hyper-Focused Targeting – We stopped bidding on anything that didn’t convert above 15%.
- Intent-Only Keyword Strategy – Every dollar went into searches that screamed “I need this procedure now.”
- Patience with Volume – We accepted a short-term dip in lead count to build long-term profitability.
It was a strategic pivot—not a spray-and-pray adjustment. Every ad was placed with surgical precision.

Business Impact
The results came fast—and they cut deep.
- CPA dropped from $250 to $104 in just a few weeks.
- Lead quality skyrocketed.
- Number of surgeries actually increased—despite lower lead volume.
Why? Because the leads coming in were ready to book, not just browsing.
Unexpected Benefits
The new campaign became a template for other markets.
Sales and marketing alignment improved — no more fighting over bad leads.
The client got their confidence back in paid media.

Emotional Impact
Instead of stressing over metrics that don’t move the needle, Wisdom Teeth Guys now get to focus on what matters: growing a profitable practice, one high-intent patient at a time.
No more second-guessing. No more budget anxiety. Just momentum.
Brand Pillar in Action: Strategy
This is what real strategy looks like—clarifying what matters, cutting what doesn’t, and aligning execution to outcomes. We didn’t optimize ads. We transformed their approach.

“We used to think in leads. Now we think in profit. It’s not just growth—it’s the right growth.”
— Wisdom Teeth Guys



