
The Problem
Fly Fish Food was a retail and e-commerce business with one of the largest selections of fly-tying supplies in the U.S. With a strong organic social media presence, Fly Fish Food had a weak spot. Paid media. The company encountered several significant challenges as it aimed to refine its digital marketing strategy and increase market share:
- Lack of Sophisticated Advertising: Fly Fish Food had never implemented a sophisticated paid advertising strategy, and previous attempts had not generated measurable results.
- Intense Competition: The online retail space for fly fishing products is competitive, with established players like Orvis, Farbank, and Simms dominating the market, which made it challenging for Fly Fish Food to stand out.
- Resource Constraints: The company lacked the necessary bandwidth and resources to execute a sophisticated marketing strategy effectively.
- Limited Budget: Starting with a constrained advertising budget limited the scope and scale of initial marketing efforts, making it crucial to optimize every dollar spent.

The Solution
To address their challenges, we collaborated on a focus strategy across three key channels: paid Google Ads, paid social, and email marketing.
Google Ads Strategy
On Google, we selected strategic keywords targeted toward high-intent search terms to capture demand effectively.
- We implemented smart bidding strategies to maximize returns even with a limited budget.
- We ran regular review and adjustment of campaign settings to optimize performance and expenditure.
Paid Social Media Playbook
In paid social media, we curated Facebook and Instagram campaigns leveraging their high-engagement organic content to connect with a dedicated community of fly fishing enthusiasts.
- We introduced dynamic retargeting ads to re-engage visitors and convert interest into sales.
- Custom audience strategies, including lookalike audiences to mimic the traits of high-value customers, expanded reach without excessive spend.
Email Marketing Tactics
Lastly, in Fly Fish Food’s email marketing, we created segmented email strategies with tailored messaging that resonated with targeted audiences based on interests and past behaviors.
- We launched automated email workflows for critical touch points like welcome series, abandoned cart recovery, and customer re-engagement.
- Our team enhanced personalization techniques to increase the relevance and effectiveness of each email sent, making each dollar go farther.

The Results
Since starting with us in 2021, Fly Fish Food saw 103% revenue growth.
- They reached 5x ROAS (return on ad spend) with 6.39x ROAS on GoogleAds by reducing acquisition costs with optimization techniques
- Email marketing revenue notably increased total sales and retention revenue from retargeting and customization
- Paid social efforts exploded user engagement across platforms, particularly with video and dynamic content leading to higher conversion rates

“As I was trying to grow my business, we had delved into the world of paid content as we were already relatively strong with organic content to acquire customers. However, we eventually realized we could not scale our internal team quickly or effectively enough to execute and manage this new revenue generation effort.
That’s where Disruptive came in. They evaluated our business model, our paid ad needs and other aspects of marketing that we were unable to handle.
Because we couldn’t bring on a full time marketing resource for this effort, Disruptive filled the need at only a small part of the cost of hiring a full time person. With their help, our paid strategies have paid off which has helped us grow our business even more. We are also effectively able to collaborate between our internal organic marketing team and the Disruptive team to generate better results on all sides of our marketing efforts. Solid combo.” —Curtis Fry, Owner

