
Initial Business Situation
Mantis, a premium provider of outdoor shooting and training gear, had recently migrated from Mailchimp to Klaviyo and brought over a massive list of 150,000+ emails. The problem? Most of the contacts hadn’t engaged in over a year.
The list sat untouched due to fear of hurting deliverability. On top of that, their email popup was underperforming at just 2.1% submission rate, and they had no discounts to incentivize signups.
Emotional State
The team knew the list held revenue potential, but pulling the trigger felt risky. They were hesitant to engage inactive contacts and uncertain how to improve capture rates without the typical discount levers.
Stagnation was the norm.

Discovery Phase
We identified two core opportunities: re-engage the dormant list without tanking deliverability and rework the signup incentive to increase conversions without undercutting the brand.
Execution
Reactivation Campaign Strategy
- Segmented the cold list by last engagement: 3, 6, 8, and 12 months.
- Sent to smaller batches, closely monitoring bounce rates.
- Ran remaining contacts through a list cleaning tool before final deployment.
Popup Conversion Optimization
- Introduced a $250 giveaway to 1% of email submissions.
- Automated winner selection and limited the number of discounts to protect margins.

Business Impact
- Re-engaged their list and grew the 90-day engaged segment from 60K to 145K contacts.
- Generated $61,000 from a single campaign.
- Increased ROI from 18x to 35x month-over-month.
- Popup conversion rate jumped from 2.1% to 5% and held steady for five months.
- Boosted welcome email open rates by 9%, click rates by 2%, and conversions by 1%.
Emotional Impact
What once felt like a gamble became a major win. The Mantis team gained confidence in their list health, saw immediate returns, and reignited momentum in their email channel.

Key Challenge We Overcame
Dormant list paralysis. Instead of letting it sit unused, we developed a safe, segmented approach that turned “cold” contacts into revenue-generating customers.

“We were sitting on a huge list we were afraid to touch. Disruptive’s strategy turned what we thought was a liability into one of our best-performing email campaigns to date. Their approach was smart, calculated, and delivered.” — Elise A., Marketing Director, Mantis



